• About Us
    • Our Team
    • What We Offer
    • Process
    • Success Stories
    • Newsletter Signup
  • Partner With Us
    • Swoop Canada
    • Venbridge
  • SR&ED Tax Credit
    • SR&ED Calculator
    • SR&ED Planning
    • SR&ED Filing Deadlines
    • SR&ED Reviews
    • SR&ED Free Webinars
  • Industries We Service
  • IRAP Funding
  • Recent News
  • 1-416-499-2861
  • info@braithwaite.ca
Free Consultation
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • What We Offer
    • Process
    • Success Stories
    • Newsletter Signup
  • Partner With Us
    • Swoop Canada
    • Venbridge
  • SR&ED Tax Credit
    • SR&ED Calculator
    • SR&ED Planning
    • SR&ED Filing Deadlines
    • SR&ED Reviews
    • SR&ED Free Webinars
  • Industries We Service
  • IRAP Funding
  • Recent News
Twitter
Linkedin
Facebook
Envelope
  • 1-416-499-2861
  • info@braithwaite.ca
Free Consultation
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • What We Offer
    • Process
    • Success Stories
    • Newsletter Signup
  • Partner With Us
    • Swoop Canada
    • Venbridge
  • SR&ED Tax Credit
    • SR&ED Calculator
    • SR&ED Planning
    • SR&ED Filing Deadlines
    • SR&ED Reviews
    • SR&ED Free Webinars
  • Industries We Service
  • IRAP Funding
  • Recent News
Twitter
Linkedin
Facebook
Envelope
All  ·  CRA  ·  SR&ED

My Business Project Failed The SR&ED Tax Credit Audit

By admin  Published On February 3, 2023

If you are reading this, a well-trained SR&ED consulting firm can tell right from the title that a business project does not qualify for the SR&ED Tax Credit. Many companies ask what the difference is or if there is any difference between a business project and an SR&ED project. The easy answer is yes there is a definite difference, but let’s dig into this further.

I think the place to start is to be clear about what the SR&ED tax credit is supposed to encourage.

The scientific research and experimental development tax credit are intended to stimulate advancements in a field of science or technology. The hope is that the advances will help innovation occur and thereby strengthen the Canadian economy.

Another way to look at it is to ask, “Do all business projects or technology projects strengthen the Canadian economy?” Certainly, some business projects and technology projects generate profit for businesses, but they are not necessarily innovative or built using new scientific or technological knowledge. So, an SR&ED claim that describes a business project or technology project fails to achieve the objective of the SR&ED tax credit program, to advance knowledge.

The SR&ED claim needs to show knowledge was developed and that it was developed with some proof that demonstrated the validity and accuracy of the knowledge. It might be tempting to think of someone with a white lab coat carrying out experiments testing a hypothesis, but the truth is many of us do this as part of our natural or usual process of working. Because of this, money is often left on the table since the claim amount doesn’t include all of the eligible activity.

Author’s side note:

As an engineer, I did not realize how deeply embedded this structured analytical process became after 4 years of university in engineering. I took it for granted that the way to solve a problem was to develop an idea (aka “a hypothesis”), testing it to see if it worked, refining the idea (or coming up with a new idea) using the test results and then starting the cycle all over again. 

If you are asking, “Well, how else would you solve a problem?“  You’d be surprised at how much is done through guesswork, without any kind of analysis.

So, the explanations of work performed in SR&ED claims (CRA’s form T661, lines 242, 244, and 246) can’t be about the business project or even the technical project (i.e. the technical work that was performed). Instead, the claim needs to

  • explain the technological obstacle (aka problem) you ran into while working on the business project or the technical project
    • “We didn’t know if a specific technological problem could be overcome.”
  • why you decided to try to solve the problem by discovering new scientific or technological knowledge, and
  • describe how you followed an iterative or cyclical process of developing a potential solution (i.e. “hypothesis”), testing the potential solution, learning from the test results and improving the potential solution for the next round of testing, learning and improving. (This is referred to as a ‘systematic process of investigation’.)
Author’s side note:

Why isn’t the work performed in a technical project good enough for an SR&ED claim?

A technical project usually consists of steps of standardized methods and processes. In other words, the knowledge of how to do the different steps is known, particular by a person who has expertise in the applicable field of knowledge (i.e., science or technology).  The claim must focus on why the new knowledge was required and how was new knowledge found.

Sometimes the failure to find a solution is incorrectly thought of as not being eligible for an SR&ED claim, but the SR&ED eligibility criteria never require success in the search for a solution to the problem. In fact, one of the approaches Braithwaite takes is to ask what failures were encountered.

>> To be continued <<

Get Innovation Funding Today

Engage our experts to optimize your SR&ED claim process, manage the compliance burden and reduce uncertainty

Contact Us


AuditCRAEligibility CriteriaSR&ED

Related Articles


All  ·  CRA  ·  SR&ED
Increase in Fraudulent SR&ED Claims Reported by Canada Revenue Agency
April 7, 2022
All  ·  SR&ED
Eligible R&D Activities in the Pharmaceutical & Medical Device Industries
January 10, 2020
All  ·  Construction & Engineering  ·  Manufacturing
Why you NEED to hire Braithwaite as your Manufacturing SR&ED Consultant
November 3, 2021
Braithwaite Canada Teams with Swoop Canada to Provide Innovative options for Business Funding
Previous Article

NAVIGATION

SR&ED Tax Credit
SR&ED Calculator
SR&ED Planning
SR&ED Filing Deadline
SR&ED Reviews
IRAP Funding
Industries We Service

NAVIGATION

Our Team
What We Offer
Process
Success Stories
Newsletter Signup
Recent News
Contact Us

TORONTO

900-2235 Sheppard Ave E
Toronto, ON M2J 5B5
Office: 1-416-499-2861
Email: info@braithwaite.ca
eFax: 1-437-889-0955

MONTREAL

102-165 Saint-Zotique West
Montréal, QC H2S 1P5
Office: 1-514-495-6590
Email: contact@abgi-canada.com

Twitter
Linkedin
Facebook
Envelope
© Braithwaite Technology Consultants Inc 2023. All rights reserved.
Privacy & Cookie Policy
CACCEPT
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

We use necessary cookies to enable you to move around our website and use its features. You may disable these by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how our website functions.
We would also like to set optional analytics cookies to help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on how you use it. However, we will not set these cookies unless you enable them by using the on/off tool below and click the save and close button. Using this tool will set a cookie on your device to remember your preferences.

For more detailed information about the cookies we use, see our Cookies Policy.
You can give or withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the ‘C’ icon at the bottom left of the website.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.

SAVE & ACCEPT